Why is a "smart indian"dangerous?
In this reading I found that "indian smart"is dangerous because he is not a statistic to his culture, he was not like all of the other kids that were not going to amount to much. Alexie had a hopes and dreams for himself and was not going to let anyone destroy his dream of becoming the person that he wanted to become, a writer and a book reader like his father.
Dangerous to whom? How could it be dangerous to be smart?
He was dangerous to his own people, and also to the non- indian people. I think that he was dangerous to his own people because of the potential he knew that he had and I think that it put fear into his class mates. They always wanted him to be quite and sit back and watch like them and it was something that he was not willing to do.
I think that he was also dangerous to the non-indian people because he would not keep quite, he was curious and eager to learn, he did not want to be thought of as stupid, because to non-indian people, indians were expected to be stupid, it was nothing out of the ordinary but Alexie was not one of those indians, he wanted to make sure that they knew this, and with his courageousness he made it dangerous to be smart.
What does it mean to be smart in contemporary U.S. society? What do people need to know and/or be able to do? And where is this learned?
I think that in today's world, the meaning of being smart is simply to have a college degree. It can be in anything, seems like if you do not have a college education these days, you are looked at differently and considered "stupid" or "ignorant". In my personal opinion I do not agree with this, I think that there are plenty of smart people in the U.S. that do not have a college degree, who earn millions of dollars a year, and there are also very smart people out there that have not even completed elementary school but yet they are more street smart more than the person with a PhD. I think that it just depends on the way that you live your life and the career path that you go down.
People need to know that they can go to school and they can learn and become successful at any given time in life. I think that for a lot of people now a days, they loose hope too soon and give up to quick. We need to get the message out there that its not to late to learn and become what you have always dreamed of. I think people also need to know that there are so many resources out there to help them. On another note I think that people also need to realize that just because you do not go to school and get an education does not mean that you are stupid, a lot people get training on the job and become very successful.
I believe that a lot of judgement on the meaning of smart is started in the home, with parents that either are successful themselves and its is important to them for there children to go to college, or parents that would like for there children to just be able to get a good job and earn a good living, and graduate high school. Both of these options in my opinion make for a smart person with high potential, I just think in todays world people are more or less frowned upon if there is not a college degree to go along with great job experience.
How is education a means to save ones life? How is Alexie attempting to save the lives of students he works with? How did Alexie save his own life?
Education can save someones life is many ways. I think that it gives people hope and it inspires them to want to become a better person, it creates confidence because it is something that no one can take away from you. No matter what you came from or how you grow up, education is something personal and gives you meaning to yourself.
Alexie is attempting to save lives of the students that he works with by visiting there schools frequently, telling his story, letting it be known that they can become anyone or anything that they want to be, he has them writing poetry, short stories, novels. They also read his books, he tries to get through to them that they are not arrogant or worthless, they are human and writing is not a bad thing its there outlet.
Alexie saved his own life by not giving up, he would not be quite, he was eager to learn and her took that eagerness and ran with it. He read books until he fell asleep at night, he wanted to become someone in life and he did that by not letting anyone tell him that he was stupid, he knew that the more reading that he did, the more educated he would become, and he was right and he is now proving that to the world by speaking out about it.
Choose a quote from the reading and share your critical thinking in response.
" I didn't have the vocabulary to say "paragraph" but I realized that a paragraph was a fence that held words. The words inside a paragraph worked together for a common purpose, they had a specific reason for being inside the same fence. This knowledge delighted me" Pg 12.
I chose this quote because I think that it is very powerful to the meaning of his story. He started out not knowing a thing. For a long time he imagined the stories in his head, he made up the stories by the pictures in the books or just made up his own theory of what the book was about. Over time he learned to read and would put the pictures together to understand the meaning of the books. When he says that the words in a paragraph were in a fence, it goes to show that he would break up the words that he was familiar with, and the pictures made sense to him and then he would piece it all together and come up with stories about what he thought he was reading. Then he finishes this quote with this delighted him, That is acknowledgment great! His imagination fascinated him, and that is all that mattered, he did not need from anyone else, he had the confidence that most didn't, and with this he is now a succssful writer.
Come up with your own question/topic on the reading.
Who do you think Alexie would of become in life if his father was not a book reader?